To me it sounds like the editor is a bit of a dunce and didn't get it herself until someone explained it. So since she didn't get it, she doesn't want it in there. Her loss, really. I think about 99% of the people would get it, your readers or other. But that's just me. *s*
The saddest thing is...she isn't the only editor out there that doesn't get stuff I do. (Sigh.)
I have a mystery anthology coming out--and I had to argue with the editor on that one--she won. It was over delayed headlights. If I took a poll, I think most people would say they've seen car headlights that stay on after you climb out, and turn off automatically.
That editor INSISTED I remove it from the manuscript because she had never seen a car that did that. And how long have they had cars with delayed headlights? YEARS.
But the bottom line in publishing is...the editor has the final say. You can argue some points, but usually, if they're set on getting rid of something, they get their way. They're like little demi-gods.
So, if you read something and all the sudden you come to a place where you blink and think, "Uh, that sounds weird," I'm guessing it's a spot where an editor rewrote a line.
I've had editors put words in--after I went through a final edit. So, it was a surprise to me when I read the book that was already on sale. They can be sneaky like that.
I fight. I stomp my feet. I say, THIS IS MY BOOK. And they say, "It's your manuscript until I pass it." Which, really, gives you the perspective.
It is only a manuscript until the editor/publisher put it on the market.
By CarysWeldonblog, at 10:17 AM
Sounds like the editor doesn't think much of her readers.
Where are the pics up for RT?
By Rinda Elliott, at 11:29 AM
Pics are up on my website: http://www.carysweldon.com/ Just look for the link that says RT 2006.
My camera stinks. Most of the pictures are dark. Of course, some of those were taken IN THE DARK at the pajama party.
By CarysWeldonblog, at 11:33 AM
Can it really be THAT hard to understand that line? I don't think it's so obscure.
See? That's what I'm saying!
My readers are quick witted. I love entendre. Give me stuff I have to think about, and can grin about later saying, "How cool, that worked both ways you could take it."
The editor thinks that doing that pulls the reader out of the story and she says that's bad. I say...hm...doesn't that make a story memorable if a reader thinks about it when they set it down?
I'll keep putting them in, and editors will keep trying to take them out. But maybe some of them will pass through.
Thanks for getting it!
By CarysWeldonblog, at 3:02 PM